Wants vs. Needs: Challenging Marketing Maxims Like a Rolling Stone

Normally, I like breathing new life into old sales and marketing maxims, but here’s one I’d like to challenge. It goes something like this: “You can’t make money selling to people based on their needs. Getting people to want your product or service is the path to sales.” Forgive me for not citing the exact wording or original author of that quote. To the best of my recollection, it came from an accomplished salesperson who made a convincing case that we humans are not rational, but rather rationalizing creatures. Search online, and you’ll find many variations of this idea and understand why it has attained untouchable status. Let’s wrestle with it.

Wants are desires – emotions that historically drive human beings to do all sorts of things, sometimes rational and in our best interests, sometimes not. But with enough self-control, passage of time, or easing of passions, wants become optional ephemera. Knowing your audience is mandatory. Consider where they fall on the emotional maturity spectrum as a potential indicator of how they may react to such sales appeals.

What’s wrong with wants?

Nothing. Don’t get me wrong; wants should be in your marcom war chest and can peacefully coexist with needs given proper positioning. Wants are great at silencing the objections emanating from your rational inner voice. You know it as the nagging adult in the room of your mind that the immature rest of your id knows it should listen to, but rarely does without a fight.

“I want ice cream now, and every day, for every meal,” says your six-year-old self.

“No,” says the adult. “I need to watch my weight and make healthy decisions, or there will be negative consequences.”

“Waahhhh!”

How loud and long your internal brat bawls determines if the adult gives in. If so, you get what you want, whether it’s daily ice cream, dresswear from an outrageously priced designer, or a new sports car you know darn well you can’t afford. You know all will make you feel great temporarily, and that assurance is enough to shove your rationality aside long enough to get you to buy. That’s the point the original author was making: Reach and motivate your sales prospect to purchase when the adult has run out of the room with fingers jammed in their ears. But sometimes the adult outlasts the baby and stays in the room, and the rational objections silence emotions. When that happens, you can’t always get what you want, which is bad news for the salesperson.

“You get what you need”

That quote I know comes from Mick Jagger, or maybe it was Keith! And wiser marketing advice you won’t hear from many other rock stars (with the exception of KISS). Permit me to riff a bit on your timeless lyrics, chaps…

Unmet needs have consequences. Unaddressed needs create a state of disquiet – a feeling things are unwise, unsafe, or unsettled. There’s a mental sting associated with unfulfilled needs; the awareness of what should be, but isn’t. And this time, you’re listening to that voice in your mind because it is talking about serious business that must be taken care of, by an adult, very soon.

Maslow taught us about the hierarchy of human needs, not wants. I learned about it in college and can attest, after 30 years in marketing, that this core concept finds application in almost all that I do professionally to this day. It bears repeating: know your audience, their needs, and where they are on Maslow’s ladder, because according to him, it is one step at a time.

Marketing-related needs are more clear-cut. “It” could be anything where the status quo isn’t acceptable and a tough decision must be made. Life is full of true, high priority needs: education to advance in life; a job and money to pay your bills; a medical procedure to save your life. All high-stakes needs requiring rational decisions. In the business world, there is no stronger call to action than a need. Sell your needs, internally or externally, and you get a decision either way. Sell wants to your boss or your B2B prospects, and risk rejection or worse.

See the difference in your inner dialogue? Wants are debatable. Needs are indispensable. Needs mean you can’t live without it as a consumer, can’t get the job done without it as a businessperson, can’t keep climbing Maslow’s ladder as a human seeking self-actualization. Needs get addressed, now or eventually. You can’t negotiate with needs. You have no choice but to accept them as mandatory, otherwise they would not be needs. And yes, marketing and salespeople do prefer when the prospect’s choices are narrowed.

So when it comes to the discussion about wants vs. needs in marketing, I don’t think you need to pick a side. I do recommend you read Maslow and listen to Mick. Needs rock!

Satisfied? If not, get in touch.